Ovid · Metamorphoses Metamorphoses

Ovid, Metamorphoses 13.121–254: The contest for the arms of Achilles: Odysseus replies

Odysseus (Ulysses) answers that Ajax's strength is of no use without the counsel that guides it, and that he, a descendant of Zeus (Jupiter), has served the Greeks as much with his mind as with his hands. He tells how he brought Iphigenia to Aulis for the common good, and how he found Achilles disguised among the daughters of Lycomedes and brought him to Troy. He tells too how he went as an envoy to Troy, and how he and Diomedes killed Dolon and Rhesus and won Rhesus' horses.

Lines 13.121–254 · 1504 words · click a number to copy its link
121Arma viri fortis medios mittantur in hostes: inde iubete peti et referentem ornate relatis?” Finierat Telamone satus vulgique secutum ultima murmur erat, donec Laertius heros 125adstitit atque oculos paulum tellure moratos sustulit ad proceres exspectatoque resolvit ora sono; neque abest facundis gratia dictis. “Si mea cum vestris valuissent vota, Pelasgi, non foret ambiguus tanti certaminis heres, 130tuque tuis armis, nos te poteremur, Achille. Quem quoniam non aequa mihi vobisque negarunt fata” (manuque simul veluti lacrimantia tersit lumina), “quis magno melius succedit Achilli, quam per quem magnus Danais successit Achilles? 135Huic modo ne prosit, quod, uti est, hebes esse videtur, neve mihi noceat, quod vobis semper, Achivi, profuit ingenium, meaque haec facundia, siqua est, quae nunc pro domino, pro vobis saepe locuta est, invidia careat, bona nec sua quisque recuset.

Ajax, the son of Telamon, stopped speech,
and murmuring among the multitude
followed his closing words, until Ulysses,
Laertian hero, stood up there and fixed
his eyes a short time on the ground; then raised
them towards the chiefs; and with his opening words,
which they awaited, the grace of his art
was not found wanting to his eloquence.
“If my desire and yours could have prevailed,
O noble Greeks, the man who should receive
a prize so valued, would not be in doubt,
and you would now enjoy your arms, and we
enjoy you, great Achilles. Since unjust
fate has denied him both to me and you,
(and here he wiped his eyes dry with his hands,
as though then shedding tears,) who could succeed
the great Achilles better than the one
through whom the great Achilles joined the Greeks?
Let Ajax win no votes because he seems
to be as stupid as the truth declares.
Let not my talents, which were always used
for service of the Greeks, increase my harm:
and let this eloquence of mine (if such
we call it) which is pleading now for me,
as it has pleaded many times for you,
awake no envy.

140Nam genus et proavos et quae non fecimus ipsi, vix ea nostra voco; sed enim quia rettulit Aiax esse Iovis pronepos, nostri quoque sanguinis auctor Iuppiter est, totidemque gradus distamus ab illo. Nam mihi Laertes pater est, Arcesius illi, 145Iuppiter huic, neque in his quisquam damnatus et exsul. Est quoque per matrem Cyllenius addita nobis altera nobilitas: deus est in utroque parente. Sed neque materno quod sum generosior ortu, nec mihi quod pater est fraterni sanguinis insons, 150proposita arma peto: meritis expendite causam, dummodo, quod fratres Telamon Peleusque fuerunt, Aiacis meritum non sit nec sanguinis ordo, sed virtutis honor spoliis quaeratur in istis! Aut si proximitas primusque requiritur heres, 155est genitor Peleus, est Pyrrhus filius illi. Quis locus Aiaci? Phthiam haec Scyrumve ferantur! Nec minus est isto Teucer patruelis Achilli: num petit ille tamen? num si petat, auferat illa?

Let each man show his best.
“Now as for ancestors and noble birth
and deeds we have not done ourselves, all these
I hardly call them ours. But, if he boasts
because he is the great grandson of Jove,
the founder of my family, you know,
is Jupiter; by birth I am just the same
degree removed from Jupiter as he.
Laertes is my father, my grandsire is
Arcesius; and my great grandsire is Jove,
and my line: has no banished criminal.
My mother's grandsire, Mercury, would give
me further claims of birth—on either side a god.
“But not because my mother's line is better
and not because my father certainly,
is innocent of his own brother's blood,
have I advanced my claim to own those arms.
Let personal merit weigh the cause alone.
Let Ajax win no credit from the fact
that Telamon, was brother unto Peleus.
Let not his merit be that he is near by blood,
may honor of manhood weigh in your award!
“But, if you seek the heir and next of kin,
Peleus is father, and Pyrrhus is the son
of great Achilles. Where is Ajax then?
These arms might go to Phthia or to Scyros!
Teucer might claim the prize because he is
Achilles' cousin. Does he seek these arms?

159Ergo operum quoniam nudum certamen habetur: 160plura quidem feci, quam quae comprendere dictis in promptu mihi sit; rerum tamen ordine ducar. Praescia venturi genetrix Nereia leti dissimulat cultu natum, et deceperat omnes, in quibus Aiacem, sumptae fallacia vestis. 165Arma ego femineis animum motura virilem mercibus inserui, neque adhuc proiecerat heros virgineos habitus, cum parmam hastamque tenenti “nate dea,” dixi “tibi se peritura reservant Pergama! quid dubitas ingentem evertere Troiam?” 170iniecique manum fortemque ad fortia misi. Ergo opera illius mea sunt: ego Telephon hasta pugnantem domui, victum orantemque refeci; quod Thebae cecidere, meum est, me credite Lesbon, me Tenedon Chrysenque et Cillan, Apollinis urbes, 175et Scyrum cepisse, mea concussa putate procubuisse solo Lyrnesia moenia dextra, utque alias taceam, qui saevum perdere posset Hectora, nempe dedi: per me iacet inclitus Hector.

And, if he did, would you allow his claim?
“Since then the contest lies in deeds alone,
though I have done more than may be well told,
I will recall them as they have occurred.
“Achilles' Nereid mother, who foresaw
his death, concealed her son by change of dress.
By that disguise Ajax, among the rest,
was well deceived. I showed with women's wares
arms that might win the spirit of a man.
The hero still wore clothing of a girl,
when, as he held a shield and spear, I said
‘Son of a goddess! Pergama but waits
to fall by you, why do you hesitate
to assure the overthrow of mighty Troy?’
With these bold words, I laid my hand on him—
and to: brave actions I sent forth the brave:
his deeds of Bravery are therefore mine
it was my power that conquered Telephus,
as he fought with his lance; it was through me
that, vanquished and suppliant? he at last was healed.
I caused the fall of Thebes; believe me, I
took Lesbos, Tenedos, Chryse and Cilla—
the cities of Apollo; and I took
Scyros; think too, of the Lyrnesian wall
as shaken by my hand, destroyed, and thrown
down level with the ground. Let this suffice:
I found the man who caused fierce Hector's death,
through me the famous Hector now, lies low!

179Illis haec armis, quibus est inventus Achilles, 180arma peto: vivo dederam, post fata reposco. — Ut dolor unius Danaos pervenit ad omnes Aulidaque Euboicam complerunt mille carinae, exspectata diu, nulla aut contraria classi flamina erant, duraeque iubent Agamemnona sortes 185inmeritam saevae natam mactare Dianae. Denegat hoc genitor divisque irascitur ipsis atque in rege tamen pater est. Ego mite parentis ingenium verbis ad publica commoda verti. Nunc equidem (fateor, fassoque ignoscat Atrides!) 190difficilem tenui sub iniquo iudice causam. Hunc tamen utilitas populi fraterque datique summa movet sceptri, laudem ut cum sanguine penset. Mittor et ad matrem, quae non hortanda, sed astu decipienda fuit: quo si Telamonius isset, 195orba suis essent etiamnum lintea ventis.

And for those arms which made Achilles known
I now demand these arms. To him alive
I gave them—at his death they should be mine.
“After the grief of one had reached all Greece,
and ships a thousand, filled Euboean Aulis;
the breezes long expected would not blow
or adverse held the helpless fleet ashore.
Then ruthless oracles gave their command,
that Agamemnon should make sacrifice
of his loved daughter and so satisfy
Diana's cruel heart. The father stood
up resolute, enraged against the gods,
a parent even though a king. I turned,
by tactful! words, a father's tender heart
to the great issue of the public weal.
I will confess it, and when I have confessed,
may the son of Atreus pardon: I had to plead
a difficult case before a partial judge.
The people's good, his brother's, and stern duty,
that followed his great office, won his ear,
till royal honor outweighed claims of blood.
I sought the mother, who could not be won
by pleading but must be deceived by craft.
Had Ajax gone to her, our thousand sails
would still droop, waiting for the favoring breeze.

196Mittor et Iliacas audax orator ad arces, visaque et intrata est altae mihi curia Troiae (plenaque adhuc erat illa viris), interritus egi, quam mihi mandarat communis Graecia causam, 200accusoque Parim praedamque Helenamque reposco et moveo Priamum Priamoque Antenora iunctum. At Paris et fratres et qui rapuere sub illo, ni tenuere manus (scis hoc, Menelae) nefandas, primaque lux nostri tecum fuit illa pericli. 205Longa referre mora est, quae consilioque manuque utiliter feci spatiosi tempore belli. Post acies primas urbis se moenibus hostes continuere diu, nec aperti copia Martis ulla fuit: decimo demum pugnavimus anno. 210Quid facis interea, qui nil nisi proelia, nosti? Quis tuus usus erat? Nam si mea facta requiris, hostibus insidior, fossas munimine cingo, consolor socios, ut longi taedia belli mente ferant placida, doceo, quo simus alendi 215armandique modo, mittor, quo postulat usus.

“As a bold envoy I was even sent
off to the towers of Ilium, and there
I saw the senate-house of lofty Troy,
and, fearless, entered it, while it was full
of heroes. There, undaunted, I spoke for
the cause which all the Greeks had given me.
Accusing Paris, I demanded back
the gold and stolen Helen, and I moved
both Priam and Antenor. All the while
Paris, his brothers, and their robber crew
could scarce withhold their wicked hands from me.
And all this, Menelaus, is well known to you:
that was the first danger I shared with you.
“I need not linger over the many things
which by my counsel and my bravery
I have accomplished through this long-drawn war.
“A long time, after the first battle clash,
the foe lay quiet within city walls,
giving no challenge for an open fight—
he stood nine years of siege before we fought
what were you doing all that tedious time,
what use were you, good only in a fight?
If you will make inquiry of my deeds:
I fashioned ambuscades for enemies;
and circled our defenses with a trench;
I cheered allies so they might all endure
with patient minds a long, protracted war;
I showed how our own army might subsist
and how it could be armed; and I was sent
wherever the necessity required.

216Ecce Iovis monitu, deceptus imagine somni, rex iubet incepti curam dimittere belli. Ille potest auctore suam defendere vocem: non sinat hoc Aiax delendaque Pergama poscat, 220quodque potest, pugnet! Cur non remoratur ituros? Cur non arma capit? det, quod vaga turba sequatur! Non erat hoc nimium numquam nisi magna loquenti. Quid quod et ipse fugit? Vidi, puduitque videre, cum tu terga dares inhonestaque vela parares. 225Nec mora, “quid facitis? quae vos dementia” dixi “concitat, o socii? captam dimittite Troiam! Quidve domum fertis decimo, nisi dedecus, anno?” Talibus atque aliis, in quae dolor ipse disertum fecerat, aversos profuga de classe reduxi. nec Telamoniades etiam nunc hiscere quicquam audet, at ausus erat reges incessere dictis Thersites etiam, per me haud impune protervus! Erigor et trepidos cives exhortor in hostem 235amissamque mea virtutem voce reposco.

“Then, at the wish of Jove, our king, deceive
by A false dream, bids us give up the war—
he could excuse his order by the cause.
Let Ajax tell him Troy must be laid low
or let him fight—at least he can do that!
Why does he fail to stop the fugitives?
Why not take arms and tell the wavering crowd
to rally round him? Would that be too much
for one who never speaks except to boast?
But now words fail me: Ajax turns and flees!
I witnessed it and was ashamed to see
you turn disgraced, preparing sails for flight.
With exclamations and without delay,
I said, ‘What are you doing? O my friends,
has madness seized you that you will quit Troy,
which is as good as taken? What can you
bear home, after ten years, but your disgrace?’
“With these commanding words, which grief itself
gave eloquence, I brought resisting Greeks
back from their purposed flight. Atrides called
together his allies, all terror struck.
Even then, Ajax the son of Telamon
dared not vouchsafe one word. But impudent
Thersites hurled vile words against the kings,
and, thanks to me, he did not miss reproof.
I rose and spoke to my disheartened friends,
reviving their lost courage with my words
from that time forth, whatever deeds this man,
my rival, may have done, belong to me.

236Tempore ab hoc, quodcumque potest fecisse videri fortiter iste, meum est, qui dantem terga retraxi. Denique de Danais quis te laudatve petitve? At sua Tydides mecum communicat acta, 240me probat et socio semper confidit Ulixe. Est aliquid, de tot Graiorum milibus unum a Diomede legi (nec me sors ire iubebat !), si tamen et spreto noctisque hostisque periclo ausum eadem, quae nos, Phrygia de gente Dolona 245interimo, non ante tamen, quam cuncta coegi prodere, et edidici, quid perfida Troia pararet. Omnia cognoram, nec, quod specularer, habebam, et iam promissa poteram cum laude reverti. Haud contentus eo petii tentoria Rhesi 250inque suis ipsum castris comitesque peremi atque ita captivo victor votisque potitus ingredior curru laetos imitante triumphos; cuius equos pretium pro nocte poposcerat hostis, arma negate mihi, fueritque benignior Aiax!

'Twas I who stayed his flight and brought him back.
“Which of the noble Greeks has given you praise
or sought your company? Yet Diomed
has shared his deeds with me and praises me,
and, while Ulysses is with him, is brave
and confident. 'Tis worthy of regard,
when out of many thousands of the Greeks,
a man becomes the choice of Diomed!
“It was not lot that ordered me to go;
and yet, despising dangers of the night,
despising dangers of the enemy,
I slew one, Dolon, of the Phrygian race,
who dared to do the very things we dared,
but not before I had prevailed on him
to tell me everything, by which I learned
perfidious actions which Troy had designed.
“Of such things now, I had discovered all
that should be found out, and I might have then
returned to enjoy the praise I had deserved.
But not content with that, I sought the tent
of Rhesus, and within his camp I slew
him and his proved attendants. Having thus
gained as a conqueror my own desires,
I drove back in a captured chariot,—
a joyous triumph. Well, deny me, then.
The arms of him whose steeds the enemy
demanded as the price of one night's aid.

People and places in this passage

English translation by Brookes More (1922). Original text: Hugo Magnus (ed.), Die Metamorphosen des P. Ovidius Naso, Gotha: F. A. Perthes, 1892 (Latin text as digitised by Perseus); English: Brookes More, Ovid's Metamorphoses, Boston: Cornhill Publishing Company, 1922.

Greek text and translation from the Perseus Digital Library, Tufts University, CC BY-SA 4.0 (Perseus Digital Library); translation public domain. Introductions, summaries and notes © GreekMythology.com.