Ovid · Metamorphoses Metamorphoses

Ovid, Metamorphoses 9.413–571: Byblis and Caunus

Themis' prophecy ends, and Byblis, a girl of Miletus, falls in love with her twin brother Caunus, and at first tries to deceive herself that it is only sisterly love. She dreams of him, and debates with herself whether she should write to him, and in the end writes a letter confessing her love. As she gives the tablets to a servant, they slip from her hands and fall.

Lines 9.413–571 · 1873 words · click a number to copy its link
413Tum demum magno petet hos Acheloia supplex ab Iove Callirhoe natis infantibus annos 415neve necem sinat esse diu victoris inultam, Iuppiter his motus privignae dona nurusque praecipiet facietque viros inpubibus annis.” Haec ubi faticano venturi praescia dixit ore Themis, vario superi sermone fremebant, 420et “cur non aliis eadem dare dona liceret” murmur erat: queritur veteres Pallantias annos coniugis esse sui, queritur canescere mitis Iasiona Ceres, repetitum Mulciber aevum poscit Erichthonio. Venerem quoque cura futuri 425tangit et Anchisae renovare paciscitur annos. Cui studeat, deus omnis habet, crescitque favore turbida seditio, donec sua Iuppiter ora solvit et “o nostri siqua est reverentia,” dixit “quo ruitis? Tantumne aliquis sibi posse videtur, 430fata quoque ut superet? Fatis Iolaus in annos, quos egit, rediit, fatis iuvenescere debent Callirhoe geniti, non ambitione nec armis.

Then shall Jupiter
let Hebe, guardian of ungathered days,
grant from the future to Callirhoe's sons,
the strength of manhood in their infancy.
Do not let their victorious father's death
be unavenged a long while. Jove prevailed
upon, will claim beforehand all the gifts
of Hebe, who is his known daughter-in-law,
and his step-daughter, and with one act change
Callirhoe's beardless boys to men of size.”
When Themis, prophesying future days,
had said these words, the Gods of Heaven complained
because they also could not grant the gift
of youth to many others in this way.
Aurora wept because her husband had
white hair; and Ceres then bewailed the age
of her Iasion, grey and stricken old;
and Mulciber demanded with new life
his Erichthonius might again appear;
and Venus, thinking upon future days,
said old Anchises' years must be restored.
And every god preferred some favorite,
until vexed with the clamor, Jupiter
implored, “If you can have regard for me,
consider the strange blessings you desire:
does any one of you believe he can
prevail against the settled will of Fate?
As Iolaus has returned by fate,
to those years spent by him; so by the Fates
Callirhoe's sons from infancy must grow
to manhood with no struggle on their part,
or force of their ambition. And you should
endure your fortune with contented minds:
I, also, must give all control to Fate.

433Vos etiam, quoque hoc animo meliore feratis, me quoque fata regunt. Quae si mutare valerem, 435nec nostrum seri curvarent Aeacon anni, perpetuumque aevi florem Rhadamanthus haberet cum Minoe meo, qui propter amara senectae pondera despicitur nec quo prius ordine regnat.” Dicta Iovis movere deos, nec sustinet ullus, 440cum videat fessos Rhadamanthon et Aeacon annis et Minoa, queri. Qui, dum fuit integer aevi, terruerat magnas ipso quoque nomine gentes. Tunc erat invalidus Deionidenque iuventae robore Miletum Phoeboque parente superbum 445pertimuit credensque suis insurgere regnis, haud tamen est patriis arcere penatibus ausus. Sponte fugis, Milete, tua, celerique carina Aegaeas metiris aquas et in Aside terra moenia constituis positoris habentia nomen. 450Hic tibi, dum sequitur patriae curvamina ripae, filia Maeandri totiens redeuntis eodem cognita Cyanee, praestantia corpora forma, Byblida cum Cauno, prolem est enixa gemellam.

“If I had power to change the course of Fate
I would not let advancing age break down
my own son Aeacus, nor bend his back
with weight of year; and Rhadamanthus should
retain an everlasting flower of youth,
together with my own son Minos, who
is now despised because of his great age,
so that his scepter has lost dignity.”
Such words of Jupiter controlled the Gods,
and none continued to complain, when they
saw Aeacus and Rhadamanthus old,
and Minos also, weary of his age.
And they remembered Minos in his prime,
had warred against great nations, till his name
if mentioned was a certain cause of fear.
But now, enfeebled by great age, he feared
Miletus, Deione's son, because
of his exultant youth and strength derived
from his great father Phoebus. And although
he well perceived Miletus' eye was fixed
upon his throne, he did not dare to drive
him from his kingdom.
But although not forced,
Miletus of his own accord did fly,
by swift ship, over to the Asian shore,
across the Aegean water, where he built
the city of his name.
Cyane, who
was known to be the daughter of the stream
Maeander, which with many a twist and turn
flows wandering there—Cyane said to be
indeed most beautiful, when known by him,
gave birth to two; a girl called Byblis, who
was lovely, and the brother Caunus—twins.

454Byblis in exemplo est, ut ament concessa puellae: 455Byblis Apollinei correpta cupidine fratris: non soror ut fratrem, nec qua debebat, amabat. Illa quidem primo nullos intellegit ignes nec peccare putat, quod saepius oscula iungat, quod sua fraterno circumdet bracchia collo, 460mendacique diu pietatis fallitur umbra. Paulatim declinat amor, visuraque fratrem culta venit nimiumque cupit formosa videri et siqua est illic formosior, invidet illi. Sed nondum manifesta sibi est nullumque sub illo 465igne facit votum: verumtamen aestuat intus. Iam dominum appellat, iam nomina sanguinis odit: Byblida iam mavult, quam se vocet ille sororem. Spes tamen obscenas animo demittere non est ausa suo vigilans: placida resoluta quiete 470saepe videt, quod amat; visa est quoque iungere fratri corpus et erubuit, quamvis sopita iacebat. Somnus abit: silet illa diu repetitque quietis ipsa suae speciem dubiaque ita mente profatur: “Me miseram! tacitae quid vult sibi noctis imago?

Byblis is an example that the love
of every maiden must be within law.
Seized with a passion for her brother, she
loved him, descendant of Apollo, not
as sister loves a brother; not in such
a manner as the law of man permits.
At first she thought it surely was not wrong
to kiss him passionately, while her arms
were thrown around her brother's neck, and so
deceived herself. And, as the habit grew,
her sister-love degenerated, till
richly attired, she came to see her brother,
with all endeavors to attract his eye;
and anxious to be seen most beautiful,
she envied every woman who appeared
of rival beauty. But she did not know
or understand the flame, hot in her heart,
though she was agitated when she saw
the object of her swiftly growing love.
Now she began to call him lord, and now
she hated to say brother, and she said,
“Do call me Byblis—never call me sister!”
And yet while feeling love so, when awake
she does not dwell upon impure desire;
but when dissolved in the soft arms of sleep,
she sees the very object of her love,
and blushing, dreams she is embraced by him,
till slumber has departed. For a time
she lies there silent, as her mind recalls
the loved appearance of her lovely dream,
until her wavering heart, in grief exclaims:—
“What is this vision of the silent night?
Ah wretched me!

475Quam nolim rata sit! cur haec ego somnia vidi? Ille quidem est oculis quamvis formosus iniquis et placet, et possim, si non sit frater, amare, et me dignus erat. Verum nocet esse sororem.— Dummodo tale nihil vigilans committere temptem, 480saepe licet simili redeat sub imagine somnus! testis abest somno, nec abest imitata voluptas. Pro! Venus et tenera volucer cum matre Cupido, gaudia quanta tuli! quam me manifesta libido contigit! ut iacui totis resoluta medullis! 485ut meminisse iuvat! quamvis brevis illa voluptas noxque fuit praeceps et coeptis invida nostris. O ego, si liceat mutato nomine iungi, quam bene, Caune, tuo poteram nurus esse parenti! quam bene, Caune, meo poteras gener esse parenti! 490Omnia, di facerent, essent communia nobis, praeter avos: tu me vellem generosior esses! Nescioquam facies igitur, pulcherrime, matrem: at mihi, quae male sum quos tu sortita parentes, nil nisi frater eris. Quod obest, id habebimus unum.

I cannot count it true.
And, if he were not my own brother, he
why is my fond heart tortured with this dream?
He is so handsome even to envious eyes,
it is not strange he has filled my fond heart;
so surely would be worthy of my love.
But it is my misfortune I am his
own sister. Let me therefore strive, awake,
to stand with honor, but let sleep return
the same dream often to me.—There can be
no fear of any witness to a shade
which phantoms my delight.—O Cupid, swift
of love-wing with your mother, and O my
beloved Venus! wonderful the joys
of my experience in the transport. All
as if reality sustaining, lifted me
up to elysian pleasure, while in truth
I lay dissolving to my very marrow:
the pleasure was so brief, and Night, headlong
sped from me, envious of my coming joys.
“If I could change my name, and join to you,
how good a daughter I would prove to your
dear father, and how good a son would you
be to my father. If the Gods agreed,
then everything would be possessed by us
in common, but this must exclude ancestors.
For I should pray, compared with mine yours might
be quite superior. But, oh my love,
some other woman by your love will be
a mother; but because, unfortunate,
my parents are the same as yours, you must
be nothing but a brother.

495Quid mihi significant ergo mea visa?—quod autem somnia pondus habent?—an habent et somnia pondus? Di melius!—di nempe suas habuere sorores: Sic Saturnus Opem iunctam sibi sanguine duxit, Oceanus Tethyn, Iunonem rector Olympi. 500Sunt superis sua iura! Quid ad caelestia ritus exigere humanos diversaque foedera tempto? Aut nostro vetitus de corde fugabitur ardor, aut hoc si nequeo, peream, precor, ante toroque mortua conponar, positaeque det oscula frater.— 505Et tamen arbitrium quaerit res ista duorum. Finge placere mihi: scelus esse videbitur illi! At non Aeolidae thalamos timuere sororum! Unde sed hos novi? Cur haec exempla paravi? Quo feror? Obscenae procul hinc discedite flammae, 510nec, nisi qua fas est germanae, frater ametur!— Si tamen ipse mei captus prior esset amore, forsitan illius possem indulgere furori. Ergo ego, quae fueram non reiectura petentem, ipsa petam! Poterisne loqui? poterisne fateri?

Sorrows, then,
shall be to us in common from this hour.
What have my night-born vision signified?
What weight have dreams? Do dreams have any weight?
The Gods forbid! The Gods have sisters! Truth
declares even Saturn married Ops, his own
blood-kin, Oceanus his Tethys, Jove,
Olympian his Juno. But the Gods
are so superior in their laws, I should
not measure human custom by the rights
established in the actions of divinities.
This passion must be banished from my heart,
or, if it cannot be so, I must pray
that I may perish, and be laid out dead
upon my couch so my dear brother there
may kiss my lips. But then he must consent,
and my delight would seem to him a crime.
“Tis known the sons of Aeolus embraced
their sisters —But why should I think of these?
Why should I take example from such lives?
Must I do as they did? Far from it! let
such lawless flames be quenched, until I feel
no evil love for him, although the pure
affection of a sister may be mine,
and cherished. If it should have happened first
that my dear brother had loved me—ah then,
I might have yielded love to his desire.
Why not now? I myself must woo him, since
I could not have rejected him, if he
had first wooed me.

515Coget amor: potero! vel, si pudor ora tenebit, littera celatos arcana fatebitur ignis: hoc placet, haec dubiam vicit sententia mentem.” In latus erigitur cubitoque innixa sinistro “viderit: insanos” inquit “fateamur amores. 520Ei mihi! quo labor? quem mens mea concipit ignem?” et meditata manu componit verba trementi: dextra tenet ferrum, vacuam tenet altera ceram. Incipit et dubitat, scribit damnatque tabellas et notat et delet, mutat culpatque probatque, 525inque vicem sumptas ponit positasque resumit. Quid velit ignorat; quidquid factura videtur, displicet. In vultu est audacia mixta pudori. Scripta “soror” fuerat, visum est delere sororem verbaque correctis incidere talia ceris: 530“Quam, nisi tu dederis, non est habitura salutem, hanc tibi mittit amans: pudet, a! pudet edere nomen. Et si, quid cupiam, quaeris, sine nomine vellem posset agi mea causa meo, nec cognita Byblis ante forem, quam spes votorum certa fuisset.

But is it possible
for me to speak of it, with proper words
describing such a strange confession? Love
will certainly compel and give me speech.
But, if shame seal my lips, then secret flame
in a sealed letter may be safely told.”
And after all this wavering, her mind
at last was satisfied; and as she leaned
on her left elbow, partly raised from her
half-dream position, she said, “Let him see:
let me at once confess my frantic passion
without repression! O my wretched heart!
What hot flame burns me!” But while speaking so,
she took an iron pen in her right hand,
and trembling wrote the heart-words as she could,
all on a clean wax tablet which she held
in her limp left hand. She begins and stops,
and hesitates—she loves and hates her hot
confession—writes, erases, changes here
and there, condemns, approves, disheartened throws
her tablets down and takes them up again:
her mind refuses everything she does,
and moves against each action as begun:
shame, fear and bold assurance mingled showed
upon her face, as she began to write,
“Your sister” but at once decided she
could not say sister, and commenced instead,
with other words on her amended wax.
“A health to you, which she who loves you fails
to have, unless you grant the same to her.

535Esse quidem laesi poterat tibi pectoris index et color et macies et vultus et umida saepe lumina nec causa suspiria mota patenti et crebri amplexus, et quae, si forte notasti, oscula sentiri non esse sororia possent: 540ipsa tamen, quamvis animo grave vulnus habebam, quamvis intus erat furor igneus, omnia feci (sunt mihi di testes), ut tandem sanior essem, pugnavique diu violenta Cupidinis arma effugere infelix et plus, quam ferre puellam 545posse putes, ego dura tuli. Superata fateri cogor opemque tuam timidis exposcere votis. Tu servare potes, tu perdere solus amantem: elige, utrum facias! Non hoc inimica precatur, sed quae, cum tibi sit iunctissima, iunctior esse 550expetit et vinclo tecum propiore ligari. Iura senes norint et, quid liceatque nefasque fasque sit, inquirant legumque examina servent: conveniens Venus est annis temeraria nostris!

It shames me, oh I am ashamed to tell
my name to you, and so without my name,
I would I might plead well until the hopes
of my desires were realized, and then
you might know safely, Byblis is my name.
“You might have knowledge of my wounded heart,
because my pale, drawn face and down-cast eyes
so often tearful, and my sighs without
apparent cause have shown it — and my warm
embraces, and my frequent kisses, much
too tender for a sister. All of this
has happened, while with agitated heart
and in hot passion, I have tried all ways,
(I call upon the Gods to witness it!)
that I might force myself to sanity.
And I have struggled, wretched nights and days,
to overcome the cruelties of love,
too dreadful for a frail girl to endure,
for they most surely are all Cupid's art.
“I have been overborne and must confess
my passion, while with timid prayers I plead;
for only you can save me. You alone
may now destroy the one who loves you best:
so you must choose what will be the result.
The one who prays is not your enemy;
but one most closely joined to you, yet asks
to knit the tie more firmly. Let old men
be governed by propriety, and talk
of what is right and wrong, and hold to all
the nice distinctions of strict laws. But Love,
has no fixed law for those whose age is ours,
is heedless and compliant.

554Quid liceat, nescimus adhuc et cuncta licere 555credimus et sequimur magnorum exempla deorum. Nec nos aut durus pater aut reverentia famae aut timor impediet (tantum sit causa timendi!). Dulcia fraterno sub nomine furta tegemus: est mihi libertas tecum secreta loquendi, 560et damus amplexus et iungimus oscula coram, quantum est, quod desit? Miserere fatentis amores et non fassurae, nisi cogeret ultimus ardor, neve merere meo subscribi causa sepulcro!” Talia nequiquam perarantem plena reliquit 565cera manum, summusque in margine versus adhaesit. Protinus inpressa signat sua crimina gemma, quam tinxit lacrimis (linguam defecerat umor), deque suis unum famulis pudibunda vocavit et pavidum blandita “fer has, fidissime, nostro”— 570dixit, et adiecit longo post tempore “fratri.” Cum daret, elapsae manibus cecidere tabellae.

And we have
not yet discovered what is right or wrong,
and all we should do is to imitate
the known example of the Gods. We have
no father's harsh rule, and we have no care
for reputation, and no fear that keeps
us from each other. But there may be cause
for fear, and we may hide our stolen love,
because a sister is at liberty
to talk with her dear brother—quite apart:
we may embrace and kiss each other, though
in public. What is wanting? Pity her
whose utmost love compels her to confess;
and let it not be written on her tomb,
her death was for your sake and love denied.”
Here when she dropped the tablet from her hand,
it was so full of fond words, which were doomed
to disappointment, that the last line traced
the edge: and without thinking of delay,
she stamped the shameful letter with her seal,
and moistened it with tears (her tongue failed her
for moisture). Then, hot-blushing, she called one
of her attendants, and with timid voice
said, coaxing, “My most trusted servant, take
these tablets to my—” after long delay
she said, “my brother.” While she gave the tablets
they suddenly slipped from her hands and fell.

People and places in this passage

English translation by Brookes More (1922). Original text: Hugo Magnus (ed.), Die Metamorphosen des P. Ovidius Naso, Gotha: F. A. Perthes, 1892 (Latin text as digitised by Perseus); English: Brookes More, Ovid's Metamorphoses, Boston: Cornhill Publishing Company, 1922.

Greek text and translation from the Perseus Digital Library, Tufts University, CC BY-SA 4.0 (Perseus Digital Library); translation public domain. Introductions, summaries and notes © GreekMythology.com.